Jonathan Feldstein – Israel Enduring Another Strike
My son called me this morning asking if I was busy. I was at home working, and he asked if I would make him a plate of macaroni and cheese and bring it to him. “I’m in my bed and hungry but comfortable and don’t want to get out of bed.”
The request was odd, and I had my son get his own food. But why he was home and in bed is the issue. Today, his school and thousands of schools across Israel are on strike. He’s 17, in 12th grade, and not bothered by being home for the day, happy to sleep some and see if he can get breakfast in bed. Nice try.
Growing up in America, where the national pastime is baseball, a strike typically refers to a batter swinging and missing the ball. Strike three and you’re out.
In Israel, baseball is not so popular, but strikes are: as in work stoppages. The year we moved to Israel there was a port worker’s strike, leaving all our household belongings in a shipping container at sea for a number of weeks, and crippling significant trade.
Strikes are not only the right of workers, in many cases, but they are also just. Employees striking for better wages, working conditions, terms of employment, etc. are legitimate.
The frequency of strikes in Israel, of the threat thereof, comes in part from its socialist past. The proclivity of worker’s unions in so many aspects of life, the economy, and throughout society is pervasive.
Yet there’s an undertone regarding strikes in Israel that’s unique, at least from my experience, though I think more common worldwide. In many instances, strikes seem to be less about a group of workers using their best asset, their labor, as leverage to get better terms. Too often they are also about disrupting society, creating havoc and annoyance, as if to demonstrate their importance as a pillar of the society/economy, almost like taking a country hostage for a day or more.
Because of the culture of trade unions throughout much of Israeli society and economy, it’s not uncommon that other unions will join in a strike by one sector to show solidarity, if not add their own demands to a wider conversation/negotiation/disruption.
This week’s striking workers started out with the teachers, beginning in pre-K, all the way through high school. Few sectors are more important than teachers. Joining the strike were workers from throughout local cities and towns across Israel. Services for social welfare, public maintenance, security, waste removal, and informal education like after-school programs are all being impacted. Only special education was not impacted.
In my town we got an email the day before, announcing the strike and not to expect such services. This gave families half a day to plan. As disruptive as the strikes are throughout Israel, the trickle-down effect was even wider. My family is a key example.
Of course, a 17-year-old 12th-grade student will be happy for a day off and elated if there’s a car to use. But families with young children who cannot stay home alone are impacted widely. My daughter and son-in-law were both impacted. A strike is disruptive to them and their ability to do work. With three children under four, they needed to juggle who would be available to watch the kids while they each tried to work as much as possible.
A positive side effect is that we got to watch and enjoy our four-year-old grandson for a few hours. Any day or excuse for that is a good day. But the secondhand impact of the strikes is felt widely. Parents who don’t have grandparents nearby to watch children who are too young to be home alone have to skip work or leave early in order to care for their kids. This is bad for an employer which rightly expects its staff to be productive, and bad for parents who are paid when they show up to work, and not paid when they don’t, or have to use a personal/sick day in order not to have their income reduced.
As much as Israeli parents may love and respect their children’s teachers, and it’s a known sore spot that Israeli teachers are grossly underpaid (a phenomenon not unique to Israel however), the broad strike impacting two million students, and probably as many parents, is disruptive and does not win public support. Maybe teachers feel they have no other choice, I don’t know. The National Parents’ Organization urged the parties to negotiate a quick solution, calling upon “the Prime Minister and the Finance Minister to (negotiate) and immediately come to solutions.” The strike’s consequences for parents are wide and deep.
The trickle-down impact of striking municipal workers joining even superseded political alliances.
As mayor of the central Israel city of Modiin, Haim Bibas is also chairman of the Federation of Local Authorities (municipalities). Despite being a staunch member of the government controlling Likud party, he lashed out at the government, “In a civilized country, the Finance Ministry would have come to us (with solutions) after four years of central government instability, when everything is in a near-state of collapse.”
“I met with (the Finance Minister) personally with my entire team two weeks ago. I sat with him.” Bibas said negotiations had started with the previous government and had been close to being concluded when new elections were called for this past fall. “It’s exactly the same process, nothing has changed, the only thing that has changed is the Finance Minister, who it turns out has no influence.”
Addressing the unusual situation of a Likud member publicly and harshly criticizing the Likud-led government, Bibas noted “The local authorities (municipalities) represent everyone… We need a grown-up to take charge. I’ve called on the Prime Minister to take the reins and start running things.”
Israeli teachers may deserve better, but so do their parents, their employers, and others who are impacted deeply yet from more of a deliberate disruption rather than what the basic elements of a strike should be about.
