French diplomat hits soldier who prevented ‘humanitarian aid’ shipment to illegal Bedouin encampment.
By Ari Soffer and Maayana Miskin for Israel National News
Tensions between Israel and the European Union over the EU boycott of Israelis living in Judea and Samaria (Shomron) may be exacerbated by a new incident in which a French diplomat struck an IDF soldier.
The incident occurred as IDF soldiers stopped a “humanitarian aid” shipment of tents and other supplies that were headed for an illegal Bedouin encampment.
The equipment was to be sent to Bedouin and foreign activists in the Jordan Valley whose illegal encampment was destroyed last week after the High Court of Justice, Israel’s Supreme Court, ruled that the structures were built without proper permits. The Bedouin claim they have lived in the area for generations.
The Israeli government has dismissed such claims as politically-motivated, noting that there are no traces or historical records of any previous Bedouin settlements in the area.
The Bedouin, along with foreign activists, have been trying to maintain a tent community at the site, with the ultimate goal of rebuilding the illegal homes.
Soldiers confiscated the EU tents and other aid, eventually resorting to riot dispersal methods after some activists attacked them with rocks.
During the scuffle, diplomat Marion Castaing accused soldiers of having “dragged me out of the [aid] truck and forced me to the ground with no regard for my diplomatic immunity.”
Initial reports of that incident triggered a stern response from the EU.
“EU representatives have already contacted the Israeli authorities to demand and explanation and expressed their concern at the incident,” said a statement from the offices of EU foreign policy chief Catherine Ashton and Humanitarian Aid Commissioner Kristalina Gergieva.
UN Humanitarian Coordinator James Rawley said Israeli authorities must “live up to their obligations as occupying power to protect those communities under their responsibility.”
However, a series of videos since released by anti-Israel activists appear to show Castaing deliberately falling to the floor, and remaining there as IDF soldiers attempt to coax her back on to her feet.
[youtube=youtu.be/QU3Hp04bzek&w=520&h=315]
But it is another piece of footage, which shows Castaing striking an Israeli soldier in the face, which has infuriated Israeli officials, with Israel’s Foreign Ministry issuing a blistering response.
[youtube=youtu.be/BW5sYRYuwn0&w=520&h=315]
“Israel rejects the one-sided announcement which was published by the spokespersons of HR Ashton and Commissioner Georgieva regarding the events in the Northern Jordan Valley. This announcement ignores the European diplomats’ blunt violation of the law, their disregard to a ruling of the Israeli court and their unnecessary provocation under the alleged pretext of humanitarian aid,” the ministry said in a statement.
The statement continued, “Diplomats are sent by their governments to be a bridge and not act as provocateurs. The European diplomats and their governments owe an explanation to this blatant violation of diplomatic codes of conduct. Israel has already made it clear that it will not accept this misconduct. Israel’s response will reflect the seriousness of these violations.”
A ministry spokesman said Israel may complain to France regarding Castaing.
Further Details:
Video contradicts French diplomat claim she was roughed up by Israeli soldiers
Posted by William A. Jacobson for http://legalinsurrection.com/
Among the many inflated claims, Israeli soldiers also are accused of pointing a gun at Castaing. On the IDF’s official blog ( the IDF has the following to say (backed up by photo evidence):
The photo us (led to spread this misinformation was taken as a screenshot from a video with footage clearly showing that Marion Castaing was neither physically dragged to the floor nor had guns pointed at her. Also, the photo clearly shows that the officer is holding his gun by the magazine, nowhere near the rifle’s grip.
Video is not always conclusive. A lot depends on camera angle.
Multiple video angles and raw video contradict the French diplomat’s claims that she was roughed up by Israeli soldiers.
There is a larger question, of course. Why are European diplomats acting as provocateurs rather than diplomats? Do Israeli diplomats in Paris participate in demonstrations against the French government?
How would France react if an Israeli diplomat led protesters attempting to circumvent a French judiciary ruling and then punched a French policeman in the face?
